Speaking of Bob Dylan; guess who's song was picked by Rolling Stone magazine as the best song of all time on their list of The 500 Best Songs Ever. Good guess.
If that list isn't big enough then maybe this one of The New York Times 1000 Best Movies Of All Time will satisfy you.
Overwhelmed by the large numbers? How about a list with just one hundred selections on it?
If it's movies you want then The Arts & Faith Top 100 Spiritually Significant Films list is probably the one for you
If books, then look no further than Image Journal's similarly themed list of 100 books.