Thursday, March 10, 2005

Art On A Desert Island

You know the routine; you've been unjustly exiled to an island for life, you will never come in contact with another human being again, you have no hope of seeking justice, no hope of escape. However, you are well equipped so your physical needs well be met and it just so happens that there is a first-rate DVD/VHS player on the island which will also play CDs. What luck! Now the hitch. The authorities are allowing you to bring only nine works of art with you; three books, three albums and three films (you may also bring a Bible if you wish without counting it in the book category). Now the question; which three of each category are you going to bring?

My choices:


1. Lord of the Rings, J. R. R. Tolkien
2. Till We Have Faces, C. S. Lewis
3. Brendan, Frederick Buechner


1. The Joshua Tree, U2
2. Sixpence None the Richer, Sixpence None the Richer
3. Mr. Buechner's Dream, Daniel Amos


1. Ordet
2. The Empire Strikes Back
3. Babette's Feast


Special thanks to midnitcafe for inspiring this post.


Tuesday's Child said...

Hey there, glad to see you are posting again, (yes, I know I should have checked sooner but I just got back from a trip.) I like your list choices, and by the way, I'm making up my book list for the next few months and I need to know just how good Brendan is... Also, here are my book choices:

1. Lord of the Rings Trilogy
2. The Genesis Trilogy (L'Engle)
3. David Copperfield

Why said...

Foolish Knight I had a thought on my blog come and see.

Why said...

My first guess is:
Book I would take Lord of the Rings
(So much reading with all that back story in the appendices at the end of the Triolgy)
Movies maybe...?
Music maybe some Beethoven possibly a u2 CD and maybe some Newsboys or the like. I am most defenitly going to have to work on this.

Will the goverment refurbish the DVDs/CDs and the like if they wear out?

Foolish Knight said...

Thankfully this is a magical island where books, albums and movies never wear down. Nifty, huh?

Queen of Arts and England said...

Now I'll say it,'Hmmm. This is hard, you make me think more than anyone else I have ever known!'

penny lane said...

wow, this is fun ...o.k let me think well, I guess I have to bring Jane Ere , because like it will take an eternity for me to finish it. hummmm... as for the other two books, probably Dr. Suess' "I'll teach my dog a hundred words", and then maybe... where's waldo. o.k now the fun stuff, movies... hummm... O.k that's a given, Ann of Green Gables, all three sets and as for music, hummmm... "Something for Everybody", "Michael Buble'" and "News Boys, 'Shine'" and then I'd need a deck of Rook Cards (is it rook or rouk? oh, well,... Can I bring a deck of cards too? huh, huh? am I here all alone with no people ... will I have to talk to myself? I'm not a very good conversationalist, and besides,(me, myself, and I) have nothing in common

eucharisto said...

Well, I think I know what I'd do for music. I'd take
1. Coldplay: A Rush Of Blood To The Head
2 Rich Mullins: A Liturgy, A Legacy, And A Ragamuffin Band
3. Bebo Norman: Big Blue Sky
I know those aren't the most spectacular choices in music, but they're the ones I like the best.
As for books (and I'm assuming this is besides the Bible)
1. Lord Of The Rings, J.R.R. Tolkien
2. The Man Who Was Thursday, G.K. Chesterton
3. The Space Trilogy (does the entire set count? It's sometimes sold as one book!)
Movies, a little bit harder, hmmm...
1. The Truman Show (it would make sense, you know, the premise of being stuck on an Island, and no one will let you get off!)
2. Finding Neverland (was one good movie, but this one's subject to change)
3. Fiddler On The Roof
Note that all of this is subject to change at any given time.

Evil Government Lawmaker Person said...

Good job guys, except for one thing. No Space Trilogy, no Genesis trilogy. The Lord of the Rings is OK because it was written as one book, I don't think it's the case with these other books. Sorry, correct me if I'm wrong, but what can I say? Life’s tough.

midnitcafe said...

I've desert island-ed all three of these on my blog, but it's more fun to start all over.

Grapes of Wrath - John Steinbeck
Lord of the Rings Trilogy (since you're allowing it as one volume)
Les miserables - Victor Hugo (In French, I'm reading the English transation currently and its a whopping 1200 pages so I figure trying to read it in French will take the rest of my life)

To Penny Lane: I am also reading Jane Eyre. How do you like it?

Live Dead - Grateful Dead
Stardust - Willie Nelson
One Fair Summer Evening - Nanci Griffith

Seven Samauri
To Kill a mockingbird

Can we build a boat to trade with each other?

eucharisto said...

actually, Mr. Evil Government Lawmaker Person, LOTR was written as three separate books, and was not made into a single volume until about a decade after, if I'm not mistaken, which I commonly am. But hopefully not this time, as I reeeallllly want to keep the space trilogy with me on my outing to a desert isle.

penny lane said...

to MidnitCafe, Thanks for giving me the (correct) spelling... I didn't have the book on hand (since, I am at work right now) and couldn't recall how "Eyre" was spelled... anyway's I am enjoying it so far though I fear you are most likely farther along than I... thanks for asking.

Princess of Mirkwood said...

This is really hard...I really do not like reading, but here lately I am really starting to like it sooo...

1. The Hobbit, J.R.R. Tolkien, because I have yet to finish it.
2. Lord of the Rings, J.R.R Tolkien, because I want to read it.
3. HALO: The Fall of the Read, Eric S. Nylund. (HAHA)

1. MMHMM, Relient K
2. 1, Beatles
3. Lose This Life, Tait

1. Pirates of the Caribbean
2. Lord of the Rings
3. Phantom of the Opera..
I think that's right...I do not know...

Why said...

remember these are the only things you will be reading, watching and listening to for the rest of your life.

midnitcafe said...

Joel, my understanding is that Lord of the Rings was originally supposed to be one giant volume, but Tolkein's publishers decided that it must be split into three parts.

You are welcome penny lane. Yes, I am nearly finnished with Jane Eyre. How far along are you? Keep reading, it is well worth the effort. The book really doesn't get good until after Lowood.

eucharisto said...

Well, if I absolutely had to pick one of the three out of the space trilogy, it would probably be That Hideous Strength. Call me weird, but that was my favorite one. But since I couldn't have the entire trilogy, I'd probably just change it to The Great Divorce, instead.

eucharisto said...

And BTW, the Genesis Trilogy is actually sold as one book, one volume. The same way we refer to LOTR as a trilogy. So unless we're going to discount LOTR, then the genesis trilogy counts, I guess.

JD said...

The Complete Works of Josephius
American Dictionary of the English Language - Naoh Webster 1828
Ben Hur

U2 - How To Dismantle....
tobyMac - Welcome to Diverse City
Relient K - The Anatomy of the Tongue and Cheek

Fiddler on the Roof
We Were Soldiers
Monty Python and the Holy Grail

Trying to get as much range as possible, so if anybody drops by we would have something to do.

penny lane said...

o.k this is sad I am only past the fourth chapter where she's about to go to school... thanks for the encouragement, I will try to press on...

Lukolas said...

2.Foxes Book of Martyrs(I've never read it but I like the whole persecuted for the faith deal and it's really big so it would take a long time to read)
3.The Hobbit

2.Relient K mmmhmmm
3.Toby Mac Welcome to Diverse City

1.LOTR(if it was up to one of LOTR it would be The Two Towers)
2.Spiderman 2
3.Bourn Sepremacy(that would be an awesome movie if I had a DVD player that had a foul language filter built into it, now if didn't, it would be Nicholas Nickleby)

There you have it, Represent.

Queen of Arts and England said...

I can't make up my mind!!! I do know that one of the albums would be The Joshua Tree, and one of the books, The Lord of the Rings, but that is all I can think of.

Oh yes, I also think we should get in addition to the Bible we should get a sketch book and never-ending pencils!

OregonCowPrincess said...

Ok...After about 5 pencils and some serious thinking here are my choices
1.Angels Vs. Demons
2.Black Beauty

1.Beatles greatest hits album
2.Phantom of the opera
3.Mercy Me- Almost there

1.Phantom of The Opera
2.Secret of Nynm
3.Sleeping Beauty

Yep those are some real weird choices...ep well...I think its this air...Theres something in it that makes you think and feel weird!...